Beto’s slow start at Fiorentina has exposed the cost of a summer transfer that left both clubs with questions. Fiorentina have spent €18m on a striker who has yet to score for them, while Everton are short of options after selling him and failing to sign Folarin Balogun. The move was meant to solve a need in Florence, but its early returns have offered little reassurance. At the same time, Everton’s decision looks harder to assess now that their own forward options have narrowed.
Everton’s move for Beto made financial sense, but the failed deadline-day pursuit of Balogun changed the picture. Thierno Barry was left as David Moyes’ only recognised striker, a thin position for a club relying on a specialist to lead the line. With that limited depth, Moyes may now see the sale in a different light. The deal can still be understood as a financial decision; the question is whether Everton had enough cover in place when it was completed.
Beto may have his own reasons to look back at his time on Merseyside. Fiorentina have struggled to replace Moise Kean, and their new arrivals have yet to fill the gap in attack. Fiorentina Uno reports that Beto has become the club’s “primary concern” among those signings. That language points to pressure around the transfer, but it doesn’t settle the more basic question: has he had enough opportunity to show what he can do?
Little return from limited minutes
The numbers underline the problem, while also demanding some care in how they’re read. In the season before his move, Beto scored 10 goals and added one assist in 40 appearances for Everton. So far this season, across Everton and Fiorentina, he has one assist and no goals in 11 appearances. Just two of those appearances have been starts, and his total playing time is 232 minutes. That’s a sharp drop in output, but a small sample of playing time makes it difficult to treat the goal tally as a settled verdict on his ability.
At Fiorentina, he has made nine appearances for 201 minutes, recording one assist. Those figures leave little room to judge his output over a full run of games, but the early signs haven’t convinced. His brief outings from the bench have done little to change the mood. A substitute appearance can give a striker little time to settle into a match, especially when the team needs an immediate attacking contribution; it can also make each quiet cameo look like further evidence of a problem.
Fiorentina signed Beto for his physical presence and ability to run into space behind a defence. Neither quality has yet translated into the impact the club expected. The gap between his previous season’s 10 goals and his current blank is stark, even with his modest minutes so far. And goals aren’t the only measure: his single assist means he has contributed once in total, though the available figures don’t explain how much of his work has helped create chances for others.
This is more significant than it looks: the dispute around Beto is partly about performance, but also about how a club judges a signing before it has given him a sustained run. The €18m price makes patience harder to defend publicly, while the lack of minutes makes a firm assessment harder to justify on the pitch. That tension can feed itself. A player under scrutiny gets shorter appearances; those appearances produce little evidence to quiet the scrutiny.
Fiorentina face a difficult decision
The manager has publicly backed the striker, but patience in Florence appears to be thinning. Supporters expected more from a player signed for €18m, and sporting director Fabio Paratici now has to weigh the poor start against the cost of giving up on him quickly. The fee is already spent, but it still shapes how the deal is discussed and how much time the club may feel it can afford to give him. A change in confidence could come before the evidence is clear.
There’s also a practical constraint: Beto has already played for Everton and Fiorentina this season, so he can’t represent another club until next season. That leaves Fiorentina needing to find a way to get more from him within their current squad. The restriction narrows the immediate choices around the striker, and it raises the value of making his role clearer: whether he’s expected to start, change matches from the bench, or offer a different kind of outlet when the attack stalls.
His previous spell at Udinese and flashes at Everton offered a basis for the move. That form hasn’t followed him to Florence yet. The next stretch of appearances will matter: Fiorentina need the striker they thought they were buying, and Beto needs the chance to show that those earlier strengths are still there. If you’re working in this space, the central issue is familiar: recruitment can identify a player’s traits, but the club still has to create the conditions for those traits to affect matches.
What the next run of games can show
Fiorentina’s next decision is less about declaring the transfer a success or failure than about gathering better evidence. A longer run of minutes would show whether Beto can turn his physical presence and movement into regular chances, and whether he can contribute when the team builds around his strengths. That said, selection isn’t a neutral experiment: the club has to balance giving him that opportunity against the need for immediate results.
Everton’s position adds another layer. The sale may have made sense when the deal was agreed, yet the failed Balogun pursuit and Barry’s status have made the loss of depth more visible. The two clubs are now dealing with different versions of the same recruitment risk: a player’s departure can leave a gap, while a new signing can take time to fit. And this is the part most people overlook: the transfer’s consequences aren’t measured only by Beto’s goals, but by how each club manages the options it has left.
There’s no clear verdict yet. Beto has too few minutes at Fiorentina for his goal record to tell the whole story, but the club’s investment and its need for a reliable attack make the slow start difficult to ignore. A proper run could change the assessment. Until then, the deal remains a concern for both sides—one trying to make a costly signing work, the other living with a thinner forward line.
The post Everton €18m exit turning into a nightmare already appeared first on Sport Witness.
