Emiliano Martínez has resumed training with Argentina less than a month after jaw surgery, but his return to full match fitness faces an unusual hurdle: he still can’t eat solid food, and he says the restriction is affecting his strength. For a goalkeeper, that matters beyond general conditioning. Training and match play demand repeated explosive movement, concentration and confidence when bodies converge near the goal; feeling weaker could make it harder to judge whether he’s ready for that workload.
The 34-year-old joined Lionel Scaloni’s squad at the team’s Ezeiza training complex on Tuesday. He hopes to feature against Uruguay on Friday and Costa Rica next Tuesday, though Argentina’s staff are weighing his readiness day by day. The schedule gives Martínez a near-term target, but it doesn’t make selection inevitable: returning to group training is one milestone, while handling the pace and contact of a match is another.
A quick return, with a physical cost
Martínez was stretchered off during the match against Everton on October 17 after colliding with Jarrad Branthwaite. The injury required surgery to repair his fractured jaw. A metal plate and four screws were fitted, and three teeth needed attention. The details point to a substantial repair, even if the early return to training might suggest a straightforward recovery.
His initial recovery estimate was about 40 days, which would have left Mike Penders with more time in goal. Martínez has returned to training earlier than that projection, but being back on the pitch hasn’t restored his usual routine. He told Página 12 that the inability to eat solid food has left him feeling weaker during sessions. That’s a practical constraint: recovery from an injury can depend on more than the repaired area, and restricted eating can make it harder to maintain the energy and strength an athlete expects from normal training.
This is more significant than it looks. A goalkeeper can be medically cleared to take part in drills and still lack the physical reserve or confidence required for a full match. Martínez’s own account makes the distinction clear: he’s training, but he doesn’t yet feel entirely like himself. (And this is the part most people overlook.) A fast return can be encouraging without proving that the underlying recovery is complete.
He recently visited a specialist and tried protective goalkeeper masks designed to reduce the risk of another blow to his jaw. He wore one briefly, but can now play without protection. That removes one possible on-field adjustment, though it doesn’t answer the bigger question of how his body will respond if he takes contact or has to make a forceful save in traffic. A return without a mask may simplify his preparation; it can’t, by itself, restore strength.
Martínez described the operation in detail: “They put in a plate with four screws and secured three teeth. They put one screw in from the outside and the rest from the inside.” The account gives a concrete sense of the repair, but the decision facing Argentina remains a sporting one: whether his current condition is enough for the demands of these matches.
Argentina will assess him before naming a starter
Martínez has told Martín Tocalli and Scaloni that he wants to play in both friendlies. “I don’t know if I’ll make the first or the second game. That will depend on contact and how things go during the week,” he said. His uncertainty is a useful counterweight to the optimism around his return. He’s expressing a preference, while leaving the final call to what happens in training.
Argentina’s coaching staff aren’t ruling out giving him minutes in both matches, possibly as a substitute, but they’re avoiding unnecessary risks while he recovers. If Martínez isn’t ready to start against Uruguay, Gerónimo Rulli and Juan Musso are the alternatives. That depth gives Scaloni room to manage the decision on its own merits rather than treating Martínez’s presence in camp as a reason to rush him into the lineup.
A substitute appearance could offer a middle ground if staff judge that he can play but shouldn’t yet take on a full match. Even then, the relevant question is how he feels during training and whether contact exposes a problem. The available information doesn’t establish that either friendly is a safe or unsafe target; it shows that Argentina intends to assess him as the week develops.
What the return will tell us
Martínez’s return to training is an encouraging step, but the next measure is whether his strength and response to contact hold up well enough for match play. Those are separate tests. The first concerns how he feels and performs in sessions; the second asks whether that level carries over when the pace, pressure and physical demands rise.
If you’re following Argentina’s preparations, the key detail isn’t simply whether Martínez appears on the team sheet. It’s whether the staff believe he can contribute without turning a promising recovery into a premature return. That said, there’s no need to treat every day of caution as a setback: his own comments describe an uncertain process, and the coaching staff are making room for that uncertainty.
For now, the picture is mixed. He’s back with the squad ahead of the 40-day estimate, yet he says he’s weaker because he can’t eat solid food, and his readiness for contact remains under assessment. Training again. Starting either match will depend on what the week shows.